Today's Flavors

We like to keep it fresh, so our flavors rotate daily! Choose a location to see today’s offerings.
Pelandale Avenue

LOW FAT
Heavenly Vanilla
Chocolate Vanilla Swirl
Classic Chocolate
Cookies N Cream
Double Stuffed Oreo
Marshmallow
Pumpkin Pie
Pumpkin Cookie Butter
Snickerdoodle Cookie Butter

NON FAT
Double Cheesecake
Original Tart

DAIRY FREE
Dole Pineapple Sorbet
Vanilla Oat Milk

NO SUGAR ADDED
Simply Vanilla
Boysenberry

Cup Sizes

63 cents per oz!

Outrageous Cups

Our custom crafted creations!
  • Snickerdoodle Cookie Butter Cup

    Heavenly Vanilla soft serve layered with our bakeshop snickerdoodle cookie dough and Biscoff cookie butter sauce.

  • Cookie Dough, Brownie, & Fudge

    Heavenly Vanilla soft serve layered with our bakeshop chocolate chip cookie dough, brownies, & Hershey’s sauce.

  • Fresh Fruit Parfait

    Heavenly Vanilla soft serve layered with fresh strawberries, kiwi, & granola.

  • Strawberry Cheesecake

    Heavenly Vanilla soft serve layered with fresh strawberries, cheesecake bites, & strawberry sauce.

  • Magic Drumstick

    Heavenly Vanilla soft serve layered with honey roasted peanuts, almonds & homemade magic shell.

  • Nutter Butter Smash

    Heavenly Vanilla soft serve layered with Reese’s Cup, Nutter Butter sauce, & Hershey’s sauce.

Our Toppings

We’re always keeping it fresh! Toppings may change regularly.
3 scoops = 1 topping
Bake Shop

NEW Sugar Cookie Dough
Reese’s Cookie Dough
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Espresso Crumble
Gluten-Free Coconut Granola
Graham Cracker Pie Crust
Cold Fudge
Brownie Crumble
Magic Shell

Classics

Animal Cookies
Bananas
Caramel Turtles
Carob Chips
Chamoy Sauce
Cheesecake Bites
Cherries
Chocolate Sprinkles
Dark Chocolate Chips
Granola
Gummi Bears
Heath Bar
Hershey’s Chocolate Sauce
Honey
Fresh Raspberries
Fresh Blueberries
Kiwi
M&Ms

Mango
Mango Boba
Mochi
Marshmallow Sauce
Nutella
Oreos
Peanuts
Peanut Butter Sauce
Pineapple
Rainbow Sprinkles
Reese’s Cup
Roasted Almonds
Sour Worms
Strawberries
Strawberry Boba
Tajin
Toasted Coconut
Yogurt Chips
Whipped Cream

Shakes

Extreme

Pumpkin Pie
Blended with Heavenly Vanilla soft serve & a slice of pumpkin pie. Topped with whipped cream & our bakeshop pie crust.

Strawberry Cheesecake
Blended with Heavenly Vanilla soft serve, cheesecake bites, strawberries & strawberry sauce. Topped with whipped cream, strawberry sauce & cheesecake bites.

Cookie Dough Brownie
Blended with Heavenly Vanilla soft serve, our bakeshop chocolate chip cookie dough and brownies. Topped with whipped cream, cookie dough & brownies.

Reese’s Peanut Butter
Blended with Heavenly Vanilla soft serve, reese’s cup & reeses’ peanut butter sauce. Topped with whipped cream & Reese’s crumble.

Oreo Mint
Blended with Heavenly Vanilla soft serve, mint Cookies & Oreos. Topped with whipped cream & Oreos.

Toffee Caramel Crunch
Blended with Heavenly Vanilla soft serve, Heath Bar & caramel sauce. Topped with whipped cream, Health Bar & caramel drizzle.

Chocolate Cake
Blended with Heavenly Vanilla soft serve & our bakeshop chocolate cake. Topped with whipped cream & dairy free fudge sauce.

Banana Nutella
Blended with Heavenly Vanilla soft serve, banana & Nutella. Topped with whipped cream & pie crust.

Classics

Oreo
Reese’s Peanut Butter
Strawberry
Reese’s Cup

Cold Brew Shakes

Cappuccino
Caramel
Mocha

Plant-Based Acai Bowls

  • Aloha Pineapple

    Dole Pineapple soft serve, coconut granola, fresh strawberries, raspberries, sliced almonds, & agave.

  • Strawberry Banana Oat Milk

    Vanilla Oat Milk soft serve, coconut granola, fresh strawberries, banana, sliced almonds, & honey

  • Cocoa Berry

    berry divine logo Plant Based Acai, coconut granola, strawberries, raspberries, toasted coconut, dark chocolate chips & agave

  • Rainbow

    berry divine logo Plant Based Acai, coconut granola, kiwis, bananas, strawberries, blueberries & agave

  • Cali Protein

    berry divine logo Plant Based Acai, coconut granola, strawberries, bananas &amp peanut butter

  • OG

    Original Tart Soft Serve, coconut granola, strawberries, kiwis &amp honey

Cookie Dough By-the-Scoop

NEW Snickerdoodle
Chocolate Chip
Reese's

Pup-Yo!

We couldn't forget our four-legged fur babies! Certified pet safe by a veterinarian, our Pup-Yo is our non-dairy vanilla served with a crunchy dog bone.

Did you know that .50 cents from every Pup-Yo sold is donated back to one of our local animal shelters? We choose a different shelter every quarter to spread the much needed love for the animals in our community!

Dowload Fundraiser Packet

Allergen Alert
Your health is of the utmost concern to us. Please be aware that Yogurt Mill products are prepared and manufactured in an environment where allergens are present (peanuts, tree nuts, soy, wheat, milk, eggs, bee pollen or gluten). For this reason, we cannot guarantee the products being served are free of any food allergens.